Panic Attack and Forced Breathing
Why breathing deeply can sometimes worsen symptoms
Introduction
Many people hear the advice to breathe deeply during a panic attack. While it helps some, for others, symptoms can worsen. This is not a contradiction but a result of how the volume and rhythm of breathing affect carbon dioxide balance and the brain's experience of air hunger.
Breathing is Not Just About Oxygen
An important function of breathing is to maintain the balance of carbon dioxide. If breathing increases excessively, the carbon dioxide concentration drops. This can cause dizziness, tingling, and a sense of unreality. These symptoms can be interpreted as dangerous, which intensifies the panic.
Deep Breaths Can Increase Ventilation Too Much
If deep breathing consists of large inhalations in rapid succession, ventilation can increase significantly. This resembles hyperventilation, even though the intent is to calm down. The result can be a drop in carbon dioxide and an intensification of symptoms.
The Effect of Control on the Nervous System
Forced breathing can also function as safety behavior. When an individual attempts to control symptoms through breathing, attention becomes locked onto the body. If the breathing attempt does not provide immediate relief, the attempt at control can increase the sense of failure and strengthen the threat prediction.
Why Calm Rhythmical Breathing Works Better
Often, slowing and steadying the breath is more effective than taking deep breaths. Slow, light, and rhythmic breathing helps the carbon dioxide balance to normalize. This reduces the dizziness and tingling that often feed the panic cycle.
The Perception of Air Hunger
Air hunger is an experience produced by the brain, based on prediction and observation. If breathing is forced, the prediction that something is wrong with breathing can be reinforced. This can increase the sensation of air hunger, even if gas exchange is adequate.
Clinical Significance
Breathing techniques can be beneficial when implemented correctly and their purpose is understood. If breathing deeply worsens symptoms, it is a signal that ventilation is increasing too much or that control is acting as reassurance. In such cases, normalizing breathing is often a better goal than achieving maximal depth.
What this means in practice
Breathing deeply can sometimes worsen panic symptoms if it increases ventilation excessively and lowers the carbon dioxide level. A more effective approach is often to slow and lighten the breath instead of forcing it. Once the role of breathing is understood, the symptom cycle can be broken earlier.
If you are experiencing a panic attack right now
The Nefio app includes a simple guided breathing tool that many people use during panic attacks to calm the nervous system.
Learn more about the neuroscience of panic: Panic Attack – The Complete Mechanism Map